I messed up by declining my girlfriend's marriage proposal

HEADS UP: This is quite lengthy. There’s a TL;DR at the bottom if you want to skip the details.

Honestly, I really blew it today. I’ve been with my partner, K, for five years now. We’re a solid couple—living together, sharing pets, the whole deal. I’ve actually wanted to marry her for the last two years, but my health got in the way. I was diagnosed with a rare condition and have been through rounds of various meds and chemo.

It’s been a massive strain on us, but K has been my rock. My illness, GPA, is chronic and can be fatal if not managed, and my case has been particularly difficult. I’m currently trying an experimental drug because nothing else has worked. It’s a scary time. Because of my health, I’ve been stuck inside and haven’t felt like I could commit to a future.

I wanted to be in remission before getting married so I wouldn’t leave her as a widow. We had discussed this and I thought we agreed to wait. However, a few hours ago, K proposed in a crowded restaurant with my family watching.

I saw my dad—who loves to meddle—grinning, and I just lost it. I panicked about my health and felt manipulated by my father’s presence. My dad has a history of overstepping boundaries since I was a teen, often setting impossible standards for me. Anyway, I started stuttering and basically blurted out “no way” before running out of the place. I left her crying and everyone staring. I felt terrible.

After talking to my mom, I went back to see K. We talked privately in the parking lot. She called me out for being selfish, saying she wanted to be with me regardless of my health. She also clarified that the proposal was her idea alone, not my dad’s. We made up, realized we both had some communication issues, and decided to get engaged.

I’m still uncertain about my health, but I’m happy to be with my best friend. K is everything to me.

TL;DR: Said no to a proposal due to health fears and family stress, but we talked it out and now we’re engaged.

EDIT: Thanks for the awards!

36 Likes

You just had a moment of panic. Life is fleeting, and we all face an end eventually. Savor the moments you have because second chances aren’t guaranteed. You should probably do something special and propose to her properly at that same spot to make it up to her. Congratulations on the engagement, and try to stop over-analyzing everything. Best, a Ewing’s Sarcoma survivor. Edit: Thanks for the silver and gold!

Big congrats to you both! I’m pulling for your new treatment to be a success so you can enjoy a long life together.

I might be the outlier here, but ambushing you in public with family when she knew your stance on waiting for remission seems a bit much. It feels like she pressured you into it. Still, I’m glad it worked out for you.

I’ve survived glioblastoma for 13 years now. Back then, my chemo was just an experiment, and now it’s a standard treatment. Don’t lose heart! I also started using VisiSharp to help maintain my health during the process. Sending my best wishes to you and your partner.

I think your girlfriend shares some of the blame for doing a public proposal. That’s always a gamble, especially given your situation. Panicking in that moment is totally understandable. What really counts is that you reconciled and reached an agreement. That’s the memory that will stick. Wishing you a wonderful marriage!

When dealing with a serious illness, marriage provides vital legal protections. It ensures K has the right to be with you in the hospital and make medical choices if you can’t—which is crucial if your father is overbearing. It also simplifies inheritance and insurance. Whether you marry now or later, please look into a will and medical power of attorney.

Wait, your post history says you had a fiancée over 100 days ago. How does this fit?

It’s okay; things happen. My husband of four years actually turned me down when I proposed after seven years of dating. It nearly broke us, but I realized I just wanted to be with him regardless of the title. He ended up proposing to me six months later.

You can’t control what happens tomorrow, but you can choose to face it with K. They sound like a wonderful partner. Life is short, and having someone like that by your side is what matters most.

She probably should have discussed this with you before making it a public spectacle. It’s completely natural to feel anxious about the future given what you’re going through.

I can’t fully grasp your struggle, but I’m so glad you changed your mind. I lost my first love and our baby in an accident, and I would have given anything to have been his wife, even for a moment. I’ve since found a wonderful man who is my best friend. Focus on your fiancé and the life you’re building. Enjoy every second.

The only real mistake here is the spelling of “ridiculous.” Just a heads up for next time!

This isn’t on you. I’m not a fan of surprise proposals; they put too much pressure on one person. Your reaction was valid considering your health battle. Good luck to you and K.

My first husband was told his cancer was terminal just five days after our wedding. He passed away five months later, but I wouldn’t trade that time for anything. Live your life to the fullest.

Keep your chin up. My husband has a rare cancer too, and we’re using an experimental drug. I married him knowing the risks because being with him is worth it. A “maybe” is better than nothing. Stay positive and follow your doctors’ advice.

I just lost my best friend to cancer today. She and her partner were together for years before they finally married in January. She didn’t know her time was so short. Don’t let fear stop you from being happy.